Comments on: Lucifer in Mumbai http://www.shahidulnews.com/2008/11/lucifer-in-mumbai/ Musings by Shahidul Alam Sun, 21 Mar 2010 10:08:17 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.1 hourly 1 By: saci http://www.shahidulnews.com/2008/11/lucifer-in-mumbai/comment-page-1/#comment-725 saci Wed, 03 Dec 2008 12:32:48 +0000 http://shahidul.wordpress.com/?p=1923#comment-725 Very moving poem. Having travelled in India 3rd class in 1970, later visited and also lived in Chennai, my heart goes out to the Belpuri wallah, and all those coming in to do the dirty work of the mega rich. The women who clean, those waiting with rickshaws and taxis - all having hit the jackpot in their humble jobs - sustaining whole families, whilst the wealthy look down on them, still don't enable them or their children opportunities for literacy and numeracy - and thinking this is the pauper's natural birthright by caste. If one dares shake this status quo in one's own little way, the megabuck chatterers are up in arms. I experienced this 1st hand when I tried to teach my driver to read, so it would help him improve his job opportunities. It breaks my heart. If the mega rich spent less on their ridiculous fashions and absurd jewellry - took a leaf or two out of the devout Jain's life philosophy, it would be a far better place. Try emulating the english Quakers who did untold good works - and many were wealthy - not the corrupt Holly Bollywood values. Very moving poem. Having travelled in India 3rd class in 1970, later visited and also lived in Chennai, my heart goes out to the Belpuri wallah, and all those coming in to do the dirty work of the mega rich. The women who clean, those waiting with rickshaws and taxis – all having hit the jackpot in their humble jobs – sustaining whole families, whilst the wealthy look down on them, still don’t enable them or their children opportunities for literacy and numeracy – and thinking this is the pauper’s natural birthright by caste. If one dares shake this status quo in one’s own little way, the megabuck chatterers are up in arms. I experienced this 1st hand when I tried to teach my driver to read, so it would help him improve his job opportunities. It breaks my heart. If the mega rich spent less on their ridiculous fashions and absurd jewellry – took a leaf or two out of the devout Jain’s life philosophy, it would be a far better place. Try emulating the english Quakers who did untold good works – and many were wealthy – not the corrupt Holly Bollywood values.

]]> By: shahidul http://www.shahidulnews.com/2008/11/lucifer-in-mumbai/comment-page-1/#comment-726 shahidul Tue, 02 Dec 2008 07:28:37 +0000 http://shahidul.wordpress.com/?p=1923#comment-726 Sent by emailL Something has bothered me as I have been watching the TV channels. Everyone is stationed outside Taj and a little bit the Oberoi but we hardly get a glimpse of the VT station and the victims there. The first 51 victims were there.I spoke to someone who has not been able to get his relatives body out for 15 hours. His relative was a bhelpuriwallah. Our media is making invisible the poor once again. I wish someone had spoken of the terror of monetary superiority in a city that puts on display plenty of it. It is intimidating to even watch the Bombay people invited to comment on TV-they know each others names, the all speak fluent English, they all were lunching and dining on a regular basis at these places, they say they want all politicians to stay out. That is very dangerous, because the politicians are the only link that the poor have with governance and if politicians are weakened , so is our democracy. It seems that the trend in thinking among the bold and beautifil is that if uniformed people have to protect the lifestyles of the elite, so be it. There was absolutely no introspection of why these targets.As always, the intelligence of the terrorists is ignored, their will to counter the hegemony of wealth and power.There are many factors at play and it would be too patronizing to write off the terrorists as any one simple thing and to reduce the dynamic of the bombings to money and by implication envy, blind instinct, poverty, etc? . More backlash is expected and the promise of vendettas will deafen the ears of calm and peace. -- Ruchira Gupta, President, Apne Aap Women Worldwide www.apneaap.org, D-56 Anand Niketan, New Delhi-21, India-110021 Sent by emailL

Something has bothered me as I have been watching the TV channels. Everyone is stationed outside Taj and a little bit the Oberoi but we hardly get a glimpse of the VT station and the victims there. The first 51 victims were there.I spoke to someone who has not been able to get his relatives body out for 15 hours. His relative was a bhelpuriwallah.

Our media is making invisible the poor once again. I wish someone had spoken of the terror of monetary superiority in a city that puts on display plenty of it. It is intimidating to even watch the Bombay people invited to comment on TV-they know each others names, the all speak fluent English, they all were lunching and dining on a regular basis at these places, they say they want all politicians to stay out. That is very dangerous, because the politicians are the only link that the poor have with governance and if politicians are weakened , so is our democracy. It seems that the trend in thinking among the bold and beautifil is that if uniformed people have to protect the lifestyles of the elite, so be it.

There was absolutely no introspection of why these targets.As always, the intelligence of the terrorists is ignored, their will to counter the hegemony of wealth and power.There are many factors at play and it would be too patronizing to write off the terrorists as any one simple thing and to reduce the dynamic of the bombings to money and by implication envy, blind instinct, poverty, etc? .

More backlash is expected and the promise of vendettas will deafen the ears of calm and peace.

–
Ruchira Gupta,
President, Apne Aap Women Worldwide
http://www.apneaap.org,
D-56 Anand Niketan,
New Delhi-21,
India-110021

]]> By: Nighat http://www.shahidulnews.com/2008/11/lucifer-in-mumbai/comment-page-1/#comment-727 Nighat Sun, 30 Nov 2008 18:29:10 +0000 http://shahidul.wordpress.com/?p=1923#comment-727 The zealot eyed are non other than inhabitants of troubled India. Where there are, as you read this, seven provinces in a state of prolonged and persistent insurgency. State sponsored zealotry in practise is India's renowned artist, M F Hussain, being denied the right to stay in India. Not satisfied with just that, now his film has been scratched from the ongoing Goa Film Festival. Cricket pitches being dug up, Christian Nuns being raped and burnt, missionaries being burned after being locked in their cars, churches turning to ashes. Muslim minority populations of Gujrat and Bombay targetted with death or destruction. Shining india IS BURNING INDIA - BURNING IN THE PYRE OF ITS INTOLERANCE.. The fig leaf of democracy is slipping. The zealot eyed are non other than inhabitants of troubled India. Where there are, as you read this, seven provinces in a state of prolonged and persistent insurgency.

State sponsored zealotry in practise is India’s renowned artist, M F Hussain, being denied the right to stay in India. Not satisfied with just that, now his film has been scratched from the ongoing Goa Film Festival.

Cricket pitches being dug up, Christian Nuns being raped and burnt, missionaries being burned after being locked in their cars, churches turning to ashes. Muslim minority populations of Gujrat and Bombay targetted with death or destruction.
Shining india IS BURNING INDIA – BURNING IN THE PYRE OF ITS INTOLERANCE.. The fig leaf of democracy is slipping.

]]>